Just last week I mentioned my first ‘real’ job working as a Motions Clerk at the Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, at the Everett McKinley Dirksen U.S. Courthouse in Chicago, Illinois. I worked there for two years, from Fall 1986 to Fall 1988. I could not help but reminisce about what was, in some ways, the best job I ever had, working for rotating panels of active judges. Unlike Elbow Clerks who work for one Judge for a period of 1 to 2 years, Motions Clerks have an opportunity to work with and get to know all of the judges. While I was in a remembering mood, it was sad to hear a few days later of the death of Judge Richard A. Posner (January 11, 1939 – November 10, 2026).
Judge Posner generally did his own drafting, so his own Elbow Clerks did not have the experience of writing opinions for him. For Motions work, however, he kept to the convention of reviewing the proposed decision prepared by the Motions Clerk – in that case, me. Judge Posner was generous with his time and always gentle in person. He also participated in the occasional Staff Attorney dinners – essentially a pot luck where the young attorneys cooked and the judges ate.
After I left the Court to enter the U.S. Foreign Service, I remember visiting him in Chambers during Home Leave two years later to tell him about my first overseas assignment at the American Embassy in London, UK. After my subsequent assignment to Main State, headquarters of the Department of State located at 2201 C Street NW, my geographic center of gravity shifted from Chicago to Washington DC and I did not keep in touch.
Over a decade later I met Judge Posner again in Washington DC in November of 2002, when he was in town for an American Enterprise Institute (AEI) event anticipating his upcoming Intellectual Property book: The Economic Structure of Intellectual Property Law, co-authored with William M. Landes. By then it has been several years since my departure from the State Department to work on global patent reform for the leading pharmaceutical trade association. I was excited to see him again at the event for his upcoming book. He looked at the card I gave him with a puzzled look on his face, and I wondered momentarily did he have absolutely no idea who I was?!
Then he said, in a slightly puzzled way (paraphrase): “But, you were supposed to be in the Foreign Service?” Realizing the source of his confusion, I explained I had been in the Foreign Service for 11 years before leaving several years earlier. As I had been afraid he did not remember me, I felt initially relieved, only then to see a crestfallen look on his face as he realized how much time had gone by. Then I felt badly that my news had inadvertently confronted him with the passage of time — essentially, his own age. Of course that was not my intention, I was just happy to see him again and pleased that he had written about Intellectual Property.
That was our last interaction – nearly 25 years ago – and now I am about two years older now than Judge Posner was at the time we met at the American Enterprise Institute in November 2002. In my 2nd Middle Age, I understand so much better the bittersweet nature of the passage of time. I get how it can seem like no time at all has passed when you see a familiar face, only to realize that more than a decade has passed. How often do we say: Where has the time gone? It just flies away.
More fundamentally, it leaves me with a feeling that I need to do more, to do better, in keeping in regular contact with those who are near and dear to my heart. So that years don’t go by willy nilly without my own realization of the passage of time.
It is also important to remember the people who were important in our personal and professional lives even when we did not stay in contact. So I am remembering fondly Judge Richard A. Posner with appreciation for both his professional accomplishments as an incredibly erudite and productive law and economics scholar and appellate judge, and his personal appreciation and kindness for everyone with whom he interacted – including young, inexperienced Motion Clerks.
























































































































































